Skip to main content

LECTURELECTURE · WEEK 9 · 26 April 2027

Week 9: Where it costs

Two cases where a translation error had a victim, and what that does to the standard of evidence this course has been using

This week

Bench
28 April 2027 What stays out of the exhibit excluding
Slides
Open the deck
Specimens

intoxicado → intoxicated

Intoxicado secondary

Nothing in this lecture is funny, and the register of this course changes here on purpose.

In 1980 a young man arrived unconscious at a Florida hospital. His family used the Spanish word intoxicado, which in that usage means poisoned or made ill by something ingested. It was taken as intoxicated. He was treated for a drug overdose. He had suffered a brain haemorrhage, and he left the hospital quadriplegic.

In 1840 the English and Māori texts of the Treaty of Waitangi did not say the same thing. The English text ceded sovereignty. The Māori text ceded kāwanatanga, and retained rangatiratanga. The disagreement is not settled and is not a curiosity.

Outline

Further reading

  1. Differences between the textsNZ History, Ministry for Culture and Heritage
  2. About the treatyWaitangi Tribunal

Teaching team